Suspension of provisional injunction to cover PI carveout for BMW supplies.
The effect of the impugned order suspended insofar as the injunction covers the BMW 2 Series Gran Coupé car model (Article 74 UPCA, R. 223 RoP). From the Statements lodged by Magna it was therefore already clear that there were six car models already on the market or soon to be introduced on the market that were fitted with the attacked embodiment.
The Court at First Instance could and should have deducted from the above mentioned documents – and if uncertain in the alternative should have asked Magna at the hearing which models should be included if such a list with exempted car models was going to be drawn up, and would thus have learned – that also the 2-series Grand Coupé should be on that list.
It was obviously wrong not to correct the impugned order by adding the 2-series Grand Coupé to the list of exempted cars.
