UPC CoA, 23 July 2024: Preservation of evidence is aimed at disclosure

09-08-2024 Print this page
IPPT20240723, UPC CoA, PMA v AWM

Application to preserve evidence or inspect premises implies a request to disclose the outcome of the measures (evidence) to the applicant and the procedure aims not merely to preserve evidence but also to disclose the evidence to the applicant (Article 60 UPCA, Rule 192 et seq. RoP). 

 

Order to preserve evidence or inspect premises must be subject to the protection of confidential information (Rule 196 RoP). Where the evidence may contain confidential information, this entails that the Court must hear the other party before deciding whether and to what extent to disclose the evidence to the applicant. The Court must hear the other party on the request for disclosure even if this party has decided not to file a remedy against the order to preserve evidence or inspect premises. 

 

For the revocation or otherwise ceasing to have effect of the measures (Article 60(8) UPCA) the Court must, as a general principle, specify in its order a time period that starts to run from the date of disclosure of the evidence to the applicant or from the date on which the Court has made a final decision not to grant the applicant access to the evidence.

 

IPPT20240723, UPC CoA, PMA v AWM